Are you talking to Heroku redis in cleartext or SSL?

In “typical” Redis installation, you might be talking to redis on localhost or on a private network, and clients typically talk to redis in cleartext. Redis doesn’t even natively support communications over SSL. (Or maybe it does now with redis6?)

However, the Heroku redis add-on (the one from Heroku itself) supports SSL connections via “Stunnel”, a tool popular with other redis users use to get SSL redis connections too. (Or maybe via native redis with redis6? Not sure if you’d know the difference, or if it matters).

There are heroku docs on all of this which say:

While you can connect to Heroku Redis without the Stunnel buildpack, it is not recommend. The data traveling over the wire will be unencrypted.

Perhaps especially because on heroku your app does not talk to redis via localhost or on a private network, but on a public network.

But I think I’ve worked on heroku apps before that missed this advice and are still talking to heroku in the clear. I just happened to run across it when I got curious about the REDIS_TLS_URL env/config variable I noticed heroku setting.

Which brings us to another thing, that heroku doc on it is out of date, it doesn’t mention the REDIS_TLS_URL config variable, just the REDIS_URL one. The difference? the TLS version will be a url beginning with rediss:// instead of redis:// , note extra s, which many redis clients use as a convention for “SSL connection to redis probably via stunnel since redis itself doens’t support it”. The redis docs provide ruby and go examples which instead use REDIS_URL and writing code to swap the redis:// for rediss:// and even hard-code port number adjustments, which is silly!

(While I continue to be very impressed with heroku as a product, I keep running into weird things like this outdated documentation, that does not match my experience/impression of heroku’s all-around technical excellence, and makes me worry if heroku is slipping…).

The docs also mention a weird driver: ruby arg for initializing the Redis client that I’m not sure what it is and it doesn’t seem necessary.

The docs are correct that you have to tell the ruby Redis client not to try to verify SSL keys against trusted root certs, and this implementation uses a self-signed cert. Otherwise you will get an error that looks like: OpenSSL::SSL::SSLError: SSL_connect returned=1 errno=0 state=error: certificate verify failed (self signed certificate in certificate chain)

So, can be as simple as:

redis_client = ENV['REDIS_TLS_URL'], ssl_params: { verify_mode: OpenSSL::SSL::VERIFY_NONE })

$redis = redis_client
# and/or
Resque.redis = redis_client

I don’t use sidekiq on this project currently, but to get the SSL connection with VERIFY_NONE, looking at sidekiq docs maybe on sidekiq docs you might have to(?):

redis_conn = proc { ENV['REDIS_TLS_URL'], ssl_params: { verify_mode: OpenSSL::SSL::VERIFY_NONE })

Sidekiq.configure_client do |config|
  config.redis = 5, &redis_conn)

Sidekiq.configure_server do |config|
  config.redis = 25, &redis_conn)

(Not sure what values you should pick for connection pool size).

While the sidekiq docs mention heroku in passing, they don’t mention need for SSL connections — I think awareness of this heroku feature and their recommendation you use it may not actually be common!

Update: Beware REDIS_URL can also be rediss

On one of my apps I saw a REDIS_URL which used redis: and a REDIS_TLS_URL which uses (secure) rediss:.

But on another app, it provides *only* a REDIS_URL, which is rediss — meaning you have to set the verify_mode: OpenSSL::SSL::VERIFY_NONE when passing it to ruby redis client. So you have to be prepared to do this with REDIS_URL values too — I think it shouldn’t hurt to set the ssl_params option even if you pass it a non-ssl redis: url, so just set it all the time?

This second app was heroku-20 stack, and the first was heroku-18 stack, is that the difference? No idea.

Documented anywhere? I doubt it. Definitely seems sloppy for what I expect of heroku, making me get a bit suspicious of whether heroku is sticking to the really impressive level of technical excellence and documentation I expect from them.

So, your best bet is to check for both REDIS_TLS_URL and REDIS_URL, prefering the TLS one if present, realizing the REDIS_URL can have a rediss:// value in it too.

The heroku docs also say you don’t get secure TLS redis connection on “hobby” plans, but I”m not sure that’s actually true anymore on heroku-20? Not trusting the docs is not a good sign.